Some Things First Nations Need to Know About Bill C-68: Proposed Amendments to the Fisheries Act


Finally, after over two years of being in power, the Liberal Government has proposed amendments to the Fisheries Act.  The Prime Minister promised to undo the gutting of the Act by former PM Harper when he did away with protections to the habitat (better known as HADD).  This was done and it a positive proposed change.

This bill has passed second reading and will now be going to a Parliamentary committee so First Nations and other interested in the fishery need to ask to go before the Standing Committee or get their written submissions in and lobby MP’s and eventually senators on needed changes to this bill.

Like all proposed legislation, there are good things and not so good things.  In light of the Liberals commitments to implement the Universal Declaration of Indigenous Rights (UNDRIP), the mandate letter to Ministers, their work on reconciliation, and Nation to Nation efforts, I would have hoped for a lot more.

There was an extensive process to ask First Nations what they wanted to see in the Fisheries Act and as usual, only parts of what was asked for was integrated into the proposed bill.  Now, going before the parliamentary committee and asking for more changes, lobbying members of parliament and the senators will be the only way to make changes that are needed to Bill C-68. Here are some things to consider and remember this is not a comprehensive review of the Bill.


s. 2.1 is amended by adding the following definitions:

Indigenous Governing Body:  means a council, government, or other entity that is authorized to act on behalf of a indigenous group, community or people that holds s.35 rights

This definition is not very clear.  A First Nations Council or Government is understandable.  But what does an entity that is authorized to act on behalf of a indigenous group, community of people that holds s. 35. Rights means?  This can be confusing as it could mean the AFN, or a tribal Council, or provincial First Nation organization. It is the First Nations themselves that holds the rights, not an “entity” or “organization”.  These rights are held collectively by the members of the First Nation in question. This definition could lead to confusion in who has the ability to exercise rights or speak about them.  Throughout the bill there is talk of an indigenous organization that is not defined causing you to wonder what an indigenous organization it.

 Laws:  includes the BY-LAWS made by an indigenous governing body.

If that body is a First Nation, this does not recognize the laws of the First Nation.  Demeans the inherent laws of the First Nations. Should be made clear it can be a law or by-law.

Indigenous, in relation to a fishery, means that fish is harvested by an Indigenous organization or any of its members for the purpose of using the fish as food, for social or ceremonial purposes or for purposes set out in a land claims agreement entered into with the Indigenous organization

Not sure how this fits into the Fisheries Act, but if there is an indigenous fishery, it is being harvested by an organization (which is undefined) not the indigenous First Nation and it is only for food, social and ceremonial or as defined in a treaty. There is no room in this definition for commercial fisheries and that is very problematic in relation to many court cases including the Ahousaht court case. The right to a commercial fishery has always been the position of First Nations.

Provisions of the Fisheries Act 

s. 2.a:  The purposes section of the Act is new but surprisingly there is no specific provision for the recognition and implementation of indigenous peoples right.  It should say something like the Act recognizes and implementsFirst Nations right to the fishery and sea resources as well as their role to manage the fishery. 

s. 2.3:  s. 35 rights cannot be abrogated or derogated by the Fisheries Act. 

This section basically says that the Fisheries Act cannot override the constitution Act and the rights recognized and affirmed there.

s. 2.4  DUTY OF MINISTER:  When making a decision, Minister SHALL CONSIDER  any adverse affect the decision may have on  s. 35 Indigenous rights

This is not a strong provision.  It does not say the Minister has to protect indigenous rights, just “shall consider”.  He can consider them and not do anything about them or decide in the public interest as we have seen in the past with projects such as Site C and Kinder Morgan.  This section really needs to be more proactive in protecting the right to fish


2.8 Considerations for Decision Making:  The Minister MAY take into consideration:

2.8(d) MAY take into consideration TK

This is too discretionary of a provision and must be changed. TK MUST be taken into consideration or the Minister can chose just scientific knowledge and leave out valuable information from First Nations. 

s. 34.1:  When preparing regulations and before recommending regulations to cabinet, they SHALL consider among other things

 s.34.1(g) traditional knowledge of the indigenous peoples of Canada that has been provided to the Minister.

Under this section, TK must be considered as opposed to s. 2.4 where it MAY be considered.

s. 61.1(2) The Minister cannot require anyone to give him traditional knowledge. 

Providing the Minister Traditional Knowledge is strictly voluntary.

61.2(1) TEK must be kept confidential unless Minister has been given written consent. 

61.2(2) TEK CAN be disclosed if it publicly available, or If Minister needs to prove their decision was free of bias and followed the rules of natural justice. OR they can use it in court proceedings. (there will be regulations to elaborate on this more 61.2 (c))

First Nations people need to know that while most of the time TEK will be confidential that it can be used publicly without your consent.  You therefore need to know that TK may be made public so FN will have to be careful what they share as there is no protection.  Or First Nation's can have input into the regulations when they are developed or you can ask for a change in the proposed bill that TK remaining confidential at all times unless consent is given. 


S. 4.1(1) NEGOTIATED AGREEMENTS: The Minister can enter into agreements with a province, any indigenous governing body or a co-management body established under a land claims agreement to further the purpose of this act including

a) facilitating cooperation between the parties to the agreement, including facilitating joint action in areas of common interest, reducing overlap between their respective programs and otherwise harmonizing those programs;

(b) facilitating enhanced communication between the parties, including the exchange of scientific and other information; and

(c) facilitating public consultation or the entry into arrangements with third-party stakeholders.

What is new to this section is that agreements can be entered into with indigenous governing bodies not just provinces.  (Purposes of agreements has not changed just reproduced them here for context.)

s. 4.2(2)(h):  The indigenous governing body the circumstances and manner in which the government of (the province) or the Indigenous governing body is to provide information on the administration and enforcement of a provision of the laws of (the province) or the Indigenous governing body that the agreement provides is equivalent in effect to a provision of the regulations.

This section allows for the agreement to include a provision that lets an indigenous law to operate like a Fisheries Act regulation. (or a provincial law does the same and this can also be problematic for indigenous people)

s. 4.2 (1) If an agreement entered into under section 4.1 provides that there is in force a provision of the laws of (the province or) the Indigenous governing body that is equivalent in effect to a provision of the regulations, the Governor in Council may, by order, declare that certain provisions of this Act or of the regulations do not apply in the province or the territory governed by the Indigenous governing body, as the case may be, with respect to the subject matter of the provision of the laws of (the province or) the Indigenous governing body.

What this section does is to let the law of the Indigenous governing body apply and not the fisheries Act if that is part of the agreement.

s. 4.1(4) The Minister shall publish an agreement in any manner they feel appropriate but agreement must be posted on website for 60 days for public comments before signing.  Minister must post a report how he dealt with the comments he received

After having negotiated an agreement for a period of time and posts it on a website for 60 days and DFO receives feedback and may see a need to make changes based on tgat feedback,  This could cause the parties to go back to the table for further negotiations and could extend negotiations a long time if they have to republish for another 60 days.

 It is difficult to know if agreements between First Nations and DFO that have been in existence for a long time would be subject to this posting.  For example, Hupacasath and Tseshaht have had yearly Sales Agreements.  They are usually completed in May or June for the fishing season.  They would have to be negotiated much earlier in order to post for 60 days comment period.  This fishery has been controversial and while some support it because of all the economic benefits it brings to the Alberni Valley, there are those that are opposed.  This would be an opportunity for negative feedback on the website and cause the kind of racial divides we saw with the trial of Gerald Stanley.

Not sure if this would include reconciliation agreements based on fishery and this should be clarified in the amended Bill.


s. 12(1):  DFO can Institute fees to recover costs for services provided. 

First Nations need to ensure that there cannot be fees for First Nations fisheries as it is our rights.  Need an exception in the act for indigenous peoples

 s. 34.1:  Factors the Minister MUST consider prior to recommending regulations to the cabinet include (d) the cumulative effects of the carrying on of the work, undertaking or activity referred to in a recommendation or exercise of power in combination with other works, undertakings or activities that have been or are being carried on, on fish and habitat. 

It is good to see that cumulative effects will be taken into consideration as this has not been a key factor in the past decision makings.  Especially in areas like the Vancouver or Nanaimo Harbours where there is so already so much development.  The continuing effect of more development affects the habitat of orcas and other fish stocks. 

 s. 34.2(4):  Before establishing any standards and codes of practice the Minister MAY consult with any indigenous governing body or any persons interested in the protection of fish or fish habitat. 

 Again there is discretion in the Minister whether he consults with any “indigenous governing body”.  The Minister MUST consult or obtain consent when any rights will be negatively impacted.  This is very clear in case law and UNDRIP.  Consent must be obtained by the First Nation who has the right, not an entity or organization. 

s. 37(2) Minister can pass regulations creating ecological sensitive areas. 

If First Nations want to designate a marine areas ecologically sensitive they have to work with Minister to create the area. This is not a given and is a timely process to engage in. 

It is interesting that the Minister can establish ecologically sensitive areas but still allow development in ecological sensitive areas with conditions.  Why have these areas designated if they can be disturbed?  DFO words  Work, undertaking of activity “is prohibited unless authorized.”  When considering a work, undertaking of activity, the minister must ensure there is conservation and protection objectives for the ecologically sensitive area can continue to exist. Therefore if the FIrst Nation goes to the trouble to create an ecological sensitve area they need to know that development can occur and have to work to impose conditions on that development to protect what is important.


It is good news that the HADD provisions have been added back into the Fisheries Act.  I have not analyzed them to any great extent in this analysis. 

What should be carefully monitored and contributed into HADD is that the Minister can define what kinds of projects are designated projects, works and undertakings and can issue permits for certain designated project types.  (S. 35.1)

 The Minister can also establish standards and codes of practice for the avoidance of the death of fish and HADD.( s. 34.2) Again, First Nations need input into these standards and code.  

 Much of the detail of the Bill will be elaborated on when it becomes law and will be in regulations and policies.


This is not meant to be a complete analysis of Bill C-68.  This is my interpretation of what could be problematic for First Nations.  IF presentations were made during the consultations, you should review what if anyting was accepted and what still needs to be advanced. 

First Nations need to get in front of the Parliamentary Committee on this act and/or make written submissions and lobby MP's and Senators when it gets to the Senate.

The Fisheries Act is a key Act that affects First Nations with fisheries and immediate attention must be given to it.  





The ruts of <a href=" Shorts Mens Black Cheap For Discount</strong></a> the years disappeared into the jungle of green trees. In that place, I carefully read the immortal green, as if I had come to the world of bliss, <a href=" Thrasher Shirt Mens And Womens Cheap For Sale</strong></a>&nbsp; smelling the immortal green smell together with the girl of autumn wind, and feeling the material of countless writers—<a href=" Long Sleeve Cheap On Sale</strong></a> we can’t With happy performance, it should be a feeling of beauty! One tree after another has escaped the shackles of last winter's cold winter, <a href=" Hoodie Flame Camo For Sale</strong></a> chasing the footsteps of spring, and now they are in a mixed era - in the most beautiful autumn, <a href=""><strong>Cheap Thrasher Hoodie On Sale</strong></a> facing the creeps; in happiness, chasing melancholy. They can't stop the steps of the years, can't get rid of nature, can only cultivate their own tenacity, <a href=" Champion Shirt Pink</strong></a> I sympathize with them, and love their lives, at least they have their own thoughts and their own bodies, with immortal souls and immortality. <a href=" Champion Jersey Red For Sale</strong></a>Green.
And their life span is shorter than some creatures, <a href=" Champion Hoodie Womens Orange On Sale</strong></a>sometimes it will be a day, and in this day it is still trying to bloom their youth, embodying the immortal green... When the autumn is high, we can hear the rhythm of , <a href=" Hoodie Mens Cheap</strong></a> and their stage is That immortal green. The footsteps are getting too fast, for us to remember that green - immortal green. With the pursuit of green, I am embarrassed. <a href=" Champion Clothing Outlet For Sale</strong></a> Touch the leaves of the leaves and feel the change of history and the innovation of the times. The car <a href=""><strong>Cheap Champion Store</strong></a>&nbsp; tracks of the years have changed, and the rhythm of life has changed. I walked into the spiritual <a href=" Mercurial Superfly 5 Chelsea</strong></a> world of Paul and realized the condensation of steel. Compared with him, I have healthy limbs. Why don’t I Can you temper his will? <a href=""><strong>Cheap Superfly 5 For Sale</strong></a> I can find myself in the green leaves. Retrieve our youth and find the motivation to live! The first section of the Chinese class used <a href=" Tiempox Ligera Iv Tf Black On Sale</strong></a> sorrowful emotions to do such beautiful things. Facing the hot sun, the team of not many people walked into the <a href=""><strong>Cheap Nike Tiempo TF For Sale</strong></a> dining hall, a few people! Defeat! Walking into the dining hall, there was a sense of intimacy. <a href=" Mercurial Superfly Cr7 Silver Cheap</strong></a> Although there were few people, it seemed to be a person. In fact, they were cooking for others. <a href=" Nike Hypervenom Men Fire Red</strong></a> The slow team, after a few minutes passed, only disappeared a few people, <a href=""><strong>Cheap Adidas Soccer On Sale</strong></a> I wanted to eat less, but could not control my mouth.
Looking forward <a href=" Ace 16.1Primeknit Fg Yellow Discount For Cheap</strong></a> to the heart of the home, the temptation is very big, today is unfortunate. Senior students turn to be unreasonable when they are reasonable, <a href=""><strong>Cheap Adidas Soccer Shoes For Sale</strong></a> and when they are unreasonable, they turn to be reasonable. Sitting on a chair with a right foot on the pedals of the table, <a href=" Adidas Nemeziz 17.1 Fg Blood Color On Sale</strong></a> I wanted to relax, but who wants the unreasonable people wants me to clean them. If not, I am going to lose 10 yuan in the next week. <a href=""><strong>Cheap Adidas Predator FG For Sale</strong></a> One of them still knows, but they don't listen to it, hehe! Laziness turned them into shepherds. I walked out of the dining hall with my head down, and stepped into the family's home on the 8th. <a href=" Predator Accelerator Fg Beckham All Red Cheap Shoes For Sale</strong></a> I tried to sue this to the class teacher. &quot;Report!&quot; The voice was extremely weak. The teacher called me in. I didn't want to open the door with my right hand. I couldn't help but cry, and I said in my heart, <a href=""><strong>Cheap Champion Hoodie</strong></a> and then I was mixed with convulsions. It seemed that there was no timidity on weekdays. The teacher asked me to go to the head teacher of the students' livestock, and I went. This time I thought of people, like the chain of &quot;people&quot; in &quot;living&quot;. Drying the tears of tears, walking on the way to the teaching building, echoing the sound of &quot;Sailor&quot;, I ran again and went to the temple of knowledge!

Hi I am looking for someone, who can write some articles for me on following topics.
Escorts Service in Delhi
Delhi Escorts Service
Escorts Service in Gurgaon
Russian Call Girls in Gurgaon
Russian Escorts in Gurgaon
Call Girls in Delhi
Escorts Service in Delhi
Delhi Escorts Service
Russian Escorts in Delhi
Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escorts in Delhi
Call Girls in Gurgaon
Russian Call Girls in Gurgaon
Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escorts in Gurgaon
Call Girls in Gurgaon
Escorts Service in Gurgaon
Russian Escorts in Delhi
Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Call Girls in Gurgaon
Escorts Service in Gurgaon
Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Escorts Service in Gurgaon
Call Girls in Gurgaon

Thank you very useful information admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here may help :

Thank you for discussing this great post. the article is very useful for me :

Thank you for sharing this article. hopefully this article can be useful for others as well I also have something useful for you too :

This post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble. You are amazing! Thanks!

Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i have been waited for so long. great share :

The post is written in very a good manner and it contains many useful information for me :

Hello, we are from the health site admin, want to share our latest articles :

Hi, I want to work with you in the health sector :

Hello, we are from the health site admin, I am very happy to look your post.
want to share our latest articles :

Hi, This Information is incredible ^_^ I want to work with you in the health sector :

Simply want to say that your article is as surprising as it could get. The neatness in your post is just perfect and I could assume you are an expert on this subject. Thank you so much for such a fine piece of information to keep myself updated, also keep such posts coming in regularly so that they help people like us. Thanks a million and please carry on the commendable work.

Given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin :

It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully.

Thank you very much because you are willing to share very useful information to many people

Thank you very much for sharing this very useful information, I am very happy to have found this information that I have been looking for

Get started office Setup with Product Key at Sign in, Enter Product Key and install Office or call us toll-free +1-888-406-4114

I am very comfortable and pleased to come here. Thank you very much.




Thank you for sharing this article. hopefully this article can be useful for others as well I also have something useful for you too.

Best article

Call +1-888-887-7208 iPhone, iPad, itunes, macintosh, macbook, apple id and Mac, technical help. Contact to apple customer service for any technical query related to apple
if you are facing Any Apple related problems call +1-855-553-4777 for instant resolution by apple support experts
Looking for Pogo number or Pogo support phone number? Contact Pogo Support by phone and get pogo help from experts. Call support number +1-866-600-0870
Pogo Customer Service games remote support from pogo experts Call +1-866-600-0870 and get complete help and support for EA Pogo games for all problems like java error, pogo games not loading, etc

Adobe support phone number for Indie Adobe Support. Check Adobe Support Article & Adobe Support Number for Independent Support. Call +1-833-800-6777
If you are facing any kind of glitches concerned with any of the Adobe product then feel free to drop a call at Adobe support number. In case, if you need any kind of further help then get in touch with our Adobe support team +1-833-800-6777 for best solutions
Looking for Microsoft number or Microsoft customer support phone number? Contact Microsoft Support by phone and get Microsoft help from experts.Call +18338006777 & Get instant resolution
Microsoft support Microsoft Support Number Call Now +18338006777 for Microsoft support and services. This is Trusted Microsoft Technical Support number provide instant support

Looking for HP Help Number? Check Independent HP Help and Support Article and HP Help Phone Number. Call +18559000490
If you are looking for the great solution for the HP products and devices, you can contact the expert team through the HP Support Number +1-855-9000-490. We are 24x7 available at whenever in online. Your Printer Solutions solve all kinds of issues or errors like PC, printers etc
Call Quickbooks Support Phone Number and get the quickest answers by QuickBooks experts. Contact Quickbooks support by phone, call +18559999877
Get QuickBooks Customer care +1-855-999-9877 number and fix all issues related QuickBooks software with QuickBooks Technical Support team. QuickBooks customer support number

Call Quicken Support Phone Number and get the quickest answers from Quicken experts. Contact Quicken support by phone, call +1-855-999-9877
Get instant support and solutions by dialing Quicken customer service number +1-855-999-9877 Talk to Quicken support and troubleshoot issues on software for Windows and Mac
Router Support Number for Indie Check Router Support Article and Router Support Phone Number for Independent Support. Call +18559000490
Contact Email Support Phone Number for Indie Email Support. Check Email Support Article and Email Support Number for Independent Support. Call +18666000870

Contact Phone number for technical support on all computer & related issues. Get instant resolution for technical concerns via phone. Contact +1-866-600-0860

Add comment

Log in or register to post comments

Latest Opportunities

First Nations Health Authority
February 14, 2019
First Nations Health Authority
February 14, 2019
First Nations Health Authority
February 14, 2019