First Nation Challenges Province's Delegation of Duty to Consult

Tuesday, March 11, 2014
By Bruce McIvor

While the Supreme Court has stated that the Crown can delegate no more than the procedural aspects of consultation, the Court has not specified the precise boundary between permissible and impermissible delegation.

The question is important to First Nations across Canada frustrated with companies purporting to 'consult' while being either incapable or unwilling to fulfill the Crown's constitutional obligations.

For example, Ontario relies heavily on mining companies to discharge the Crown's duty to consult and accommodate obligations. I've commented earlier on this aspect of Ontario's new Mining Act:

Our client, Wabauskang First Nation, has raised the issue as part of their challenge to Ontario's authorization of a proposed gold mine in Treaty 3. The written arguments have now been filed:

The hearing is scheduled for Toronto during the week of April 14th.
The case has the potential to clarify the law and create an important precedent for First Nations, industry and governments across the country. 

Bruce McIvor is principal of First Peoples Law Corporation.

Contact Bruce

For more First Peoples Law comments see our publications page

Latest Opportunities

Senior First Nations Relations Advisor

Ministry of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations and Rural Development
January 11, 2022

Communications Officer

First Nations Public Service Secretariat
January 10, 2022

Coordinator, Elders in Residence Programs, Indigenous Health

Vancouver Coastal Health
January 6, 2022